Issue 40
· Junior news!
As the nights are drawing in, Fantasy Bob has been hard at work compiling another action-packed edition of the newsletter. He has also invested several empire biscuits to engage the services of a top-end marketing company to rebrand the newsletter. In this issue of “The Arrow” there is news of the forthcoming European adventure for the 1st XI; a review of the playing records of Scotland’s T20 World Cup stars as Grange Loan; Gav Rittoo reports on his recent gig at the Scotland Zimbabwe series; as well as a look back at how the club fared 50,100 & 150 years ago and much, much more.
If you would like contribute a piece to future editions or have any ideas for content – please get in touch at newsletter@carltoncc.co.uk

Text of this page
The Newsletter of Carlton Cricket Club
22 November 2021 Issue 40
JUNIOR NEWS!
Many congratulations to
Jane and Fraser on the
arrival of Rory David James
Watts, who came to the
crease on Friday 19
November weighing a
handsome 7lbs 5oz.
Rory has been pencilled in
for his first match in the 5th
XI in 2032.
NEWSLETTER NEWS
Given the end of official Lockdown many months ago, it seems right to re-badge
the Newsletter. I hope it meets with approval.
The new name is drawn from the club’s crest and reflects the copious hashtagging
on its social media.
As ever, the future of this Newsletter is dependent on contributions from across
the club. Any ideas for content will be gratefully received - a favourite match - a
distant memory - personal news - something to get off your chest? Let us know.
Newsletter@carltoncc.co.uk

Text of this page
Our European Adventure
There is an early start next year for Carlton’s cricketers as they take part in
ECL22 the so called Champions League of European cricket, to be held in Malaga
in February. In a 3 day blitz, Carlton will play Turkish, Czech, Swiss, Romanian,
and Italian club champions in a round robin T10 format for a place in March’s
finals.
Carlton is very grateful for the support of CALA Homes, Chambers Tutoring,
Umair Mohammed Dentistry, and Ben Property in this exciting venture.
There will be more on the opposing teams in coming Newsletters, but in the
meantime here are some language tips for the players to add to their practice
drills.
Phrase
Turkish
Czech
Romanian
Italian
Swiss
(German)
How's that
O nasil
Jakto
Cum e
Com’e quello
Wei ist das
Middle and
leg
Orta ve bacak
Stred a noha
Mijloc si picior
Mezzo e
gamba
Mitte und bein
Reverse
swing
Ters salincak
Zpetny vykyv
Leagan invers
Oscillazione
inversa
Ruckwartssch
wung
Rain
stopped
play
Yagmur
oyunu
durdurdu
Dest prestal
hrat
Ploaia a oprit
jocul
La oggia ha
semsso di
giocare
Regen hat
aufgehort zu
spielen
@EuropeanCricket

Text of this page
PURPLE HAZE
Scotland’s cricketers have returned with
heads
held
high
following
their
adventures in the recent T20 World Cup.
Next year they do it all again in
Australia.
It is all very well strutting your stuff on
the world stage, but how have the squad
members fared at the biggest stage of
all - Grange Loan?
A number of the squad have yet to make
their debut at Grange Loan - their
careers have been based in the south or
the west.
While skipper Kyle Coetzer’s appearances
may have been limited to pre-season
friendly visits with his club Benwell Hill,
others have came in search of league
or cup glory. How have they fared
against the might of Carlton?
The
table
on
the
next
page
summarises their best performances.
The most frequent visitor has been
Safyaan Sharif with 12 appearances.
He first came to Grange Loan as a
junior with Largo in 2006. He took a
couple of wickets but his Dad stroked
115*. Since then Safyaan has played
at GL with a range of club and
representative sides, most recently in
2018 with Glenrothes.
Maybe it is no surprise that the best
bowling figures are Mark Watt’s 5-30
in 2014, or that the best batting has
been by George Munsey who has 2
GL
centuries
from
his
7
visits.
(Members of the 4th XI are confident
that neither knock is a patch on his
110 at the Meadows when he turned
out for Musselburgh 2 in a League 8
encounter in 2010.)
Carlton’s own Ali Evans has made 127
appearances at GL with best bowling
6-19 v StewMel in 2021 and a top
innings of 108 v Corstorphine in
2020.

Text of this page
Player
Appear-
ances at
GL
Team
Best Batting
Best Bowling
Safyan
Sharif
12
Largo
Dunfermline
Glenrothes
Scotland u19
National Academy
Clydesdale
SCU President's XI
Falkland
92 (Falkland)
28/5/16
7.2-1-19-4
Nat Acad
15/8/2010
Craig
Wallace
11
Forfarshire
National Academy
SCU President's XI
62 SCU
President's XI
6/8/2013
Mark Watt
9
Heriots
57
6/7/2017
13-1-30-5 16/8/14
George
Munsey
7
Grange
Watsonians
177* Grange
6/6/2015 101
Watsonians
5/5/2018
Michael
Leask
6
Stoneywood Dyce
Forfarshire
National Academy
88 S/woodDyce
31/8/2013
11-2-42-2
17/5/2014
Chris
Greaves
5
Glenrothes
Forfarshire
162 (v2ndXI)
22/08/2015
81 (v1stXI)
14/05/2016
3.5-0-25-3 (v2ndXI)
28/6/2014
10-0-54-1 (v1stXI)
14/05/2016
Richie
Berrington
5
Greenock
Clydesdale
SCU President's XI
101 (ret) (SCU
President's XI)
6/8/2013
6-1-29-1 (Clydesdale)
2/9/2016
Dylan Budge
4
Grange
22
23/7/2018
6.4-1-28-2
5/8/2020
Matthew
Cross
3
Heriots
Aberdeenshire
41* A’shire
30/5/2009
Calum
McLeod
1
SCU President's XI
5
6/8/2013
7-0-21-1
6/8/2013
THE PURPLE LIDS
AT GRANGE LOAN

Text of this page
As I’m sat here writing this on a Saturday
afternoon, I’ve been thinking about what
brings us cricketers together. I can tell you
one thing for sure, we all miss it when
we’re not playing. I’m finding myself
already checking Twitter for the scores,
seeing if the lads have done the job. But it
isn’t just playing the game we all love that
I’m missing. It’s being part of a club like
Carlton.
For those readers who don’t know me, I’ve
played for Carlton for the last few years,
mainly opening the batting for the Two’s .
Sadly, I’ve had to cut my Carlton career
short, having moved to London half way
through this season. You can take this
passage as my note of thanks to you and
everyone else at the club that will always
hold a special place in my heart.
That bond you feel towards the club you
play for is special. We all feel it, and
sometimes it’s difficult to explain to
anyone not clued up on the sport. It’s not
just
about
playing,
it’s
everything
in-between,
and
Carlton
Cricket
Club
embodies everything I love about cricket.
It’s the one club mindset. Despite the huge
depth at the club, putting out 6 sides
every weekend (4 of which I’ve been lucky
enough to play for), there are no divisions.
We come together as one, challenging
each other in training and helping each
other become better.
I remember being gutted after losing a
2nd team match, and then 10 minutes
later celebrating with the boys when we
heard the One’s had just won. It might be
a team game played by individuals, but at
Carlton we all thrive when our teammates
do well. This, by the way, really helps
when the Ump has triggered you early
doors for the second week running.
It’s also the club rivalries. There’s no
better feeling than singing with your
mates after beating that team you love to
hate. I’d say the rivalries are healthy at
Carlton. They motivate us to stay that
little bit longer at training and work that
extra bit harder in the middle. It hurts
when you lose, but that just makes the
beer taste so much sweeter when you
win.
Most of all though, it’s the people that
make Carlton. The players, the members,
your pals. The people that get the game
on at the weekend, prepare the ground
and pour the pints. The people that coach
the juniors, run the camps and nurture
the next generation. The people that
make the moments you remember; great
catches and grind-it-out innings’, last-ball
nail biters and dressing room beers, big
hits and bigger nights out. The people
that are worth staying out with in Subway
‘til 3am on a Tuesday night, who won’t let
you go home when you’re working the
next day, who play the odd rain card
(sorry Skip) dancing to Abba tunes the
night before a game. This is what club
cricket is all about.
I was grateful to be asked to contribute to
the newsletter. It’s given me the chance
to say a proper thank you to everyone
who’s welcomed me at the club and
helped create memories I’ll have for a
very long time. I miss playing already,
but I’ll miss this club even more. It’s been
an absolute honour. I wish all the teams
the best of luck for the future and I hope
to see you all again.
Go well (and up the
Arrows)!
MISSING
CHRIS
We were
sorry to
see Chris
McAllister’s
career take
him to
London
mid-season
Another 50 for Chris

Text of this page
‘In the spring of 1871 matters were
so much down that a meeting of the
seven or eight remaining members
was held in the Old Ship Hotel East
Register
Street
to
consider
the
questions of winding up the Club’s
affairs. The question however was
never mooted as J H I Macfarlane
then and there proposed sixteen men
for membership amongst whom were
several
well-known
English
public
school cricketers; so the situation was
saved and a capital season’s cricket
carried out.’
Macfarlane, a physician at the Royal
Infirmary, was an all round athlete - a
brilliant short distance runner, long
jump and hurdles champion who
played
rugby
for
Scotland
at
‘quarter-back, half-back and forward.’
Macfarlane had earlier that year played
in the first ever rugby international
between Scotland and England - a
victory for Scotland. As far as cricket
goes, he is described as a steady bat and
one of the last underarm bowlers. He
was vice-captain of Carlton and had
been leading run scorer in 1870.
He died tragically young in 1874 at the
age of 22. He had rheumatic fever
complicated with pericarditis attributed
to having lain on the cold ground for
some time after dislocating his knee in a
rugby match.
Christie had suffered a leg injury on the
football field and so was always granted
a runner when batting. He bowled slow
leg breaks, taking only two short steps
of a run up.
NL Stevenson records that Carlton’s
match record in 1871 was 9 wins and 4
defeats out of 13 games played.
After flirting with winding up, Carlton
went
on
to
prosper
and
in
the
subsequent
year
sponsored
the
Gentlemen of Edinburgh v United South
of England match which brought WG
Grace to Edinburgh (see NL 18) and
restored the Club’s finances.
THE PAST IS ANOTHER
COUNTRY
Historians will remember 2021 as
one
of
the
most
successful
seasons in Carlton’s history. We
take a look at the history books to
find out how the club did 150, 100
and 50 years ago.
1871 saw the opening of the Royal
Albert Hall and the publication of Alice
Through the Looking Glass. Carlton
Cricket Club was a mere 8 years old.
There had been successes, but the
future seemed uncertain.
In his 1904 Retrospect of the early
years of Carlton, one time Secretary
and skipper, Robert Christie records:

Text of this page
In 1921 as society gradually recovered
from the shattering impacts of the First
World War, cricket continued to emerge
from its hibernation. MCC had toured
Australia in the winter and suffered a
5-0 whitewash - and were to face a
further 3 defeats in the Ashes series
that
summer.
The
Irish
War
of
Independence was at its height. But
under the captaincy of NL Stevenson,
the early ‘20s were a golden period at
Grange Loan.
At the end of the 1921 season the
Scottish Field attempted to establish a
‘Scottish Cricket Championship.’ The
records of 43 leading clubs over the
season were examined. They reported:
‘The Carlton Cricket Club have finished
another wonderful season and must
rightly
be
acknowledged
the
most
powerful side in Scotland.’
Carlton played 27 matches winning 24 -
losing only one (to Grange!)
The
Edinburgh
Evening
Dispatch
reported:
‘The great side of the season was the
Carlton. They have an array of talent
such as many clubs must have envied.
The Carlton play the correct Saturday
afternoon cricket - quick scoring all the
time. Even if they had to face a big
total, which was seldom, they were
always out to get the runs if it were
reasonably possible.’
Vice captain CS Paterson was the
season’s leading player - scoring 944
runs with a highest score of 138* at an
average of 37.76. He also took 102
wickets @7.12. Paterson was capped
11
times
for
Scotland
between
1913-27, captaining the side on two
occasions.
The batting was bolstered on occasion
by the appearance of GW Jupp, one of
brightest stars of pre-war Scottish
cricket. NL Stevenson says - ’it wasn’t
safe to hold a garden party within 100
yards of Grange Loan while George
Jupp was having his innings.’
1921 - A Golden
Year

Text of this page
At the end of the heady summer of
1971, during which Chirpee Chirpee
Cheep Cheep had topped the charts,
Carlton finished third in the then East
League
behind
Stenhousemuir
&
Grange. Under the leadership of Alun
Davies
Carlton
played
10
league
matches (suggesting a somewhat wet
summer) of which they won 6, lost two,
and drew two. Wins were against
Edinburgh
University,
Watsonians,
Cupar,
Royal
High,
Heriot’s,
Leith
Franklin. Matches with Stenhousemuir
and Edinburgh Accies were drawn and
there were losses to Kirkcaldy and
Grange.
Outside the league, Carlton lost in the
third round of the Masterton Trophy to
West Lothian and in the first round of
the
National
knock-out
to
Stenhousemuir, for whom Brian Hardie
scored 31 (before going on to play for
Essex for many years). Carlton also
lost
in
the
second
round
of
the
Rothmans Quaich to West of Scotland,
for whom Pakistani Test cricketer
Salahuddin scored an undefeated 101.
Carlton First XI 1971 Back Row - Chris Paul (scorer), George Innes, Fraser Dall (Jnr), Eddie
Harper, Tony Clarkson, William Borthwick, Gus Reoch, Frank Millar, Jimmy Jappy; Front Row
Jeremy Weatherhead, Alun Davies (Capt) Fraser Dall (Snr) (Pres) Chris Smith, Bruce Dixon.
Notable players not in the photo included Archie Gray Alan Kemp and Norman Shanks.
1971
Topping the season’s averages were:
batting, Fraser Dall, whose 7 innings
yielded 254 runs @ 50.80. His highest
score of 84* at Grange Loan against
Edinburgh University was also the
highest score of the season. Top
bowler was George Innes with 28
wickets @ 20.44.
The best bowling performance was
however by Tony Clarkson who took
8-20 (7 bowled) at Leith Franklin.
Clarkson was an Australian medic. He
spent 3 years conducting research in
Edinburgh before returning to Adelaide
via London. He became a leading
specialist on kidney disease. He died in
2011 and is well remembered in this
obituary.
On 27 June there was an intra-club
Single Wicket competition; Alun Davies
defeated Chris Smith in the final. In
the first round, AR Clarkson scored one
run but defeated Bruce Dixon, out
without scoring!
The second XI also finished third in
their league with 8 wins out of 11
matches. Ten friendlies were also
played.

Text of this page
I think I was nine or ten, and living in
Dundee, when cricket grabbed me and I
acquired my first bat, pads and primitive
gloves with spiky rubber. By the time I
was at secondary school we had moved to
Stirling. Alongside the school teams, I had
begun
to
go
to
Stirling
County’s
Williamfield where a group of us played
together on the outfield until we were old
and good enough to graduate to the nets.
It must have been 1959 or thereabouts
when I first played regularly for Stirling
County’s 1st XI but the following year I left
for St Andrews University where I had a
not very distinguished season (the only
Scot in the University team!) before, in the
following three summers, succumbing to
persuasion to come home to play for the
County from the start of the season. In
the autumn of 1964 I moved to Edinburgh
to start a civil service job in the then
Scottish Office. The choice as to where to
play cricket there was not difficult: since
the FP teams were not then open to
outsiders, it was either Carlton or Grange;
and,
having
played
against
both
in
friendlies and cup matches, the decision
was straightforward and soon confirmed by
the warm welcome I received and the
seven very happy seasons that followed.
I was never a stylish or very good
batsman (I think I should now say
‘batter’!!), had few bowling aspirations,
and always enjoyed fielding. I usually
opened the batting but was really a bit of
a right-hand ‘hacker’ with a tendency
towards impatience and getting out too
early – but there was always much good
batting to follow. During my time at
Grange Loan we never won the East
League but we were almost there or
thereabout – second, third or fourth.
There was a continuing turnover of
players
(medics,
university
staff
or
post-graduates,
others
coming
to
Edinburgh to work then leaving again) but
some stalwarts were ever-present: I
remember especially the redoubtable Alun
Davies, captain throughout my time at the
club, Chris Smith, a fine all-rounder, Fred
Dall, barman and later President, Ian
Ewen, club treasurer, 2nd XI captain and
wit extraordinaire, Chris Paul, scorer, and
Jimmy Jappy, umpire, groundsman and
much else: without their commitment the
club would scarcely have survived. /cont’d
50 YEARS
ON
SEVEN HAPPY
YEARS AT
GRANGE LOAN
Norman Shanks
(Carlton Cap 119)
Vice Captain 1971
As his article recounts, Norman left the
Civil Service in 1979 to train for the
Ministry and enjoyed a distinguished
Church career, including a number of
years as Leader the Iona Community -
full details can be found in this link.

Text of this page
/cont’d
I have few particular memories apart from
the occasion probably in the late 1960s
when, in a cup match against West of
Scotland at Hamilton Crescent, I scored a
streaky and very lucky 50 that included six
over long-off off Intikhab Alam, later to be
Pakistan captain, by whose leg-spin and
googlies I was totally bewildered. Looking
back on my experience of facing the fastest
bowlers of the time without the helmet,
thigh-
and
arm-pads
that
are
now
customary (and only box and a hankie in
my left-hand trouser pocket for protection!)
sends a shiver down my spine! But my
overall recollection of these years at
Grange Loan is very warm and positive –
the camaraderie, bonding and sense of
shared
purpose;
laughter,
mutual
encouragement and support; the regular
fixtures home and away and stimulating
post-match
conversations;
sunny
afternoons and evenings in that attractive
setting.
I had always said that my love of cricket
was so strong that I would go on playing as
long as I could run! So it was something of
a surprise that the 1971 season was my
last ‘serious’ one. By then I had been club
secretary for a few years and that year was
also appointed club vice-captain. But on
top of that there were other significant
responsibilities: our daughter was born in
1969 and our elder son in February 1971;
church commitments were taking up more
time, above all the opening, in May that
year, of a community project, of which I
was joint chair, involving a coffee house
open late-night at weekends in the west
end of the city centre; and my civil service
work too was cranking up big-time, with
extensive consultations and the preparation
of legislation to reform local government.
It was perhaps hardly surprising that my
cricketing form plummeted that season:
the runs dried up, and the joy went out of
fielding to the extent that I could scarcely
be relied upon to catch the simplest
‘dolly’; so, with some reluctance but a
degree of inevitability, I hung up my bat.
Since then my interest in following cricket
–
particularly
at
international
and
first-class level, and the history of the
game - has never disappeared. As our
sons were growing up it was a joy that
they came to share my enthusiasm and to
surpass my ability and achievements.
When
my
appointment
at
Glasgow
University led to a move westwards, they
decided to join not West of Scotland but
Hillhead,
which
played
then
in
the
Glasgow and district league. I cannot
resist recounting my pleasure when, in a
Scottish Cup match at Hughenden (I think
in around 1991) Hillhead defeated Carlton
and my younger and elder sons scored
respectively 84 and 54: I still have the
cutting from The Herald, when Monday’s
edition faithfully reported all the weekend
scores! I am glad to say that the youngest
of our grandsons, aged 10, has inherited
the
family
enthusiasm,
has
joined
Hillhead’s excellent junior section, and
shows signs of considerable promise both
as a batter and a left-arm quickie: I
always found them the hardest bowlers to
contend with! Sadly our daughter’s two
teenage (footballing!) sons in Edinburgh ,
despite my intermittent efforts, have
never really ‘caught the bug’; but there
may still be time. And our elder son, who
now lives not far from Grange Loan, has
become a fairly regular spectator there
and invariably sends me texts to keep me
up to date with what is happening.
My very best wishes to you all.

Text of this page
When the message slid into my DMs a month
ago, I couldn’t help contain my excitement.
Finally, my time had come to share the story
of my first season back at Carlton after some
time out. I was deliberating about whether to
lead with a ball-by-ball account of my 6 for
whatever at Inch Park for the 3s, or whether to
start by explaining how I had managed to
make my way through a full season without
being required to bat once(!) Alas there
seemed to be no interest in hearing my tales of
tearing up the ESCA leagues.
No, what the Newsletter was after was a
behind the scenes scoop on my first attempt at
stadium announcing, DJ-ing and how I chose
such a banging playlist for the Scotland v
Zimbabwe T20 series in September.
So starting with stadium announcing - if there
is one thing you need to perfect in this game
it’s pronunciation. Growing up with a name like
Rittoo, I understand how infuriating it can be
when people get it wrong, so I was determined
to get everyone’s name right.
Looking at the Scotland squad there were
plenty of household names in there. The likes
of Evans, Watt and Sole - all familiar faces who
have made their way up through the ESCA
leagues.
What
I
liked
most
about
the
aforementioned individuals and the rest of the
Scotland Squad for that matter was that their
names were predominantly easy to pronounce.
MOnosyllables
all!
In
comparison,
the
Zimbabwean
team
threw
up
sterner
challenges.
After many a sleepless night - waking up in
a cold sweat trying to remember how to
pronounce top-order batsman Tadiwanashe
Marumani, I eventually got the hang of it.
This was down to a great chat I had with the
Zimbabwean team manager one hour before
the first ball. He went through every squad
member’s name with me, told me exactly
how to pronounce each one and advised me
to write names down phonetically to make
them easier to read. A huge help and a
great tip for future!
In terms of the music - that was a slightly
simpler task. Press play. Press pause. That’s
what all DJ’s do right…?
In all seriousness, picking the playlist
proved
a
time-consuming,
and
thought-provoking
exercise.
Much
like
playing the front foot drive - balance is
crucial. Crowd pleasers, traditional Scottish
songs, a couple of 'proper bangers' as
resident Carlton DJ - DJ RuMac (Ruari
Macpherson) - would describe them all
featured. Mix them in with a couple of
weather-related songs - Umbrella (Rhianna),
Here Comes the Sun (The Beatles, Why
Does it Always Rain on Me (Travis) - and
some ABBA classics (at the team's request)
and there you go. You can listen to Gav’s
playlist here!
Choosing the song was only half the battle.
After each boundary or fall of wicket, we
would play on a short sting of music - so the
night
before
each
match
was
spent
skimming through each song to make sure
the music was cut at the perfect part of the
track. Again, much like the front foot drive –
timing is everything.
All fun and games off the field, and on the
pitch - three entertaining and closely fought
games
which
makes
the
task
of
"entertaining" fans a whole lot easier
GAVIN RITTOO
Playing to the crowd at Scotland
v Zimbabwe
The only blemish in
what
was
a
thoroughly enjoyable
experience? Having to
drink out of a Grange
Cricket
Club
mug.....but
I’ll
live
with that.

Text of this page
Brian Adair
Brian Adair, Carlton cap 31, played twice
for Carlton at the age of 17 in 1952 before
beginning
his
long
association
with
Watsonians.
He played over 400 games for that club
and was a past Captain. He was a past
President of the Scottish Cricket Union and
President of the East League. He was
Senior Partner of Rydens who sponsored
the East League for many years.
Brian was also a great friend of Carlton – a
club Patron who also gave a generous
donation towards the fundraising for the
new pavilion.
David Macpherson
David Macpherson, Carlton cap 74, played
40 matches for the Carlton First XI
between 1959 and 1961.
Better
known
at
Grange
Loan
more
recently as the father of our Immediate
Past President Andy and grandfather of
Kyle and Ruari, David was seen proudly
following their progress through the junior
ranks into the top teams at Grange Loan,
modestly taking credit for imbuing his love
of cricket in them.
David was a dashing left-hand middle order
bat with sound technique. Although only
an occasional bowler, his accurate medium
pace proved useful from time to time.
David has the distinction of a 5 wicket haul
(5-14 v Edin City Police in 1959). Since
Andy achieved this on several occasions,
David is part of the only father and son
combination at Carlton to share this
honour.
In Memoriam
Carlton has been saddened to receive news of the recent passing of
two good friends and holders of First XI Caps. Deepest sympathy is
extended to their families.

Text of this page
A few issues of the Newsletter ago, the
question was asked which Carlton player
could
be
considered
Scotland’s
most
successful skipper, boasting a 75% win
record?
The answer is none other than new father
and Director of Cricket, Fraser Watts.
Fraggle took the reins 4 times in 2008,
leading the side to victory against Canada,
Bermuda and Lancashire but narrowly losing
a rain affected match to Derbyshire.
Grange Loan Goes into Hibernation
An expert squad recently enjoyed the Autumn sunshine as they put the ground
onto its winter footing.
Are you sure this
thing will fly?
Solving the Rubik’s
cube for another
year.
Skipper Quiz
