Issue 67
· It must be a record
Now that the season is well underway Fantasy Bob has been hard at work producing another bumper edition of The Arrow. In this month’s edition there is a deep dive into the record books after Chris McBride’s huge innings against Meigle in EPL week 2. There is also a piece on Aberdeenshire CC and the various connections with Carlton which is particularly timely as we are due to face them in the next round of the Scottish Cup this Sunday. Also in this issue Lewis O’Donnell reports on his successful winter Down Under; David Ponniah recalls the 1988 season which culminated in Carlton winning the Scottish Cricket “Team of the Year” and much, much more.

Text of this page
The Newsletter of Carlton Cricket Club
May 2024 Issue 67
FOLLOW CARLTON
FOLLOW CARLTON
ALL CARLTON KIT IS
NOW AVAILABLE
DIRECT FROM
GRAY NICHOLS
ALL CARLTON KIT IS
NOW AVAILABLE
DIRECT FROM
GRAY NICHOLS
IT MUST BE A RECORD

Text of this page
Scores over 200
Chris’s innings is the highest scored by a
Carlton player.
It is the first score over 200 by a Carlton
batter since Ali Shah scored 207* in 2013 for
the Second XI against Watsonians 2. Prior to
that the only Carlton player to top 200 had
been in 1908 when George Jupp scored 202*
against Royal High School FP.
Highest Scores in Scottish Cricket
Chris’s innings equals the highest in the
Eastern Premier League. George Munsey was
dismissed for 220, for Watsonians at Falkland
in 2017. There is one other score of 200 in
the EPL - Matthew Cross scored 200* for
Heriot’s against Arbroath United in 2021.
However the highest scores in league matches
in Scotland happened in the now defunct
Borders League. In 1976 Rae Nichol blasted
232 for Gala against Selkirk (for whose soccer
team
he
was
goal-keeper)
which
was
exceeded in 1989 by Steve Carr’s 254 for
Langholm against Lanark.
Big scores may be even less frequent in the
lower leagues, but they do happen. In 2010
Ritchie Bartsch scored 236* against MDAFS 4
It must be a record
How do Chris McBride’s innings of 220*, and the First XI’s total of 420-3 on 11 May
stand in the record books?
Fastest Scoring Rate
Chris’s innings came off 115 balls and included
24 4s and 11 6s. His strike rate was 192.98.
Munsey faced 125 balls and hit 25 4s and 12
6s, a strike rate of 176.00. Cross faced 162
balls had 18 4s and 7 6s and had a strike rate
of 123.5.
as newly formed Teuchters CC entered the
leagues for the first time. He would later that
season hit 91 at Grange Loan against Carlton
4. Teuchters disbanded in 2016.
Highest Scores at Grange Loan
It is the highest individual score at Grange
Loan.
The previous highest individual innings was
177* scored by George Munsey for Grange in
2015. In 1999 Zahoor Elahi scored 170 for
SMRH.
The previous highest by a Carlton batter was
Ollie Rae’s 171* in 2016 against Galloway.
The highest by a male Carlton batter was by
Gordon Drummond with 169 against Renfrew
in the 2011 Cup Tie. The highest score by a
Carlton male batter in a league match was
Fraser Watts’ 162 against Falkland in 2017.

Text of this page
Carlton Women’s victory over Galloway in
2016 was by 260 runs which is GL’s biggest
margin. The biggest margin in the EPL is
Watsonians’ crushing of Falkland by 314 in
2017.
Ancient History
But there is a long way to go to reach the
highest total ever recorded in a Scottish
cricket match - in 1919 the Australian Imperial
Forces XI relaxed after their efforts on the
Western Front by scoring 733-6 against
Western District Select at Shawholm.
The highest individual innings recorded on
Scottish soil was in 1898 when W H Holms
scored 303* for Blair Lodge School against
Campsie. Blair Lodge was a public school on
the English model and was attended by NL
Stevenson. It had a formidable record in
sports.
Holms was the school captain and was
selected to play for Scotland at rugby while
still at school. Blair Lodge School closed in
1904 - the property subsequently becoming a
Borstal and most recently Polmont Young
Offenders Institution.
As referred to in the previous issue of The
Arrow, the highest innings by a Scottish batter
is Stewart Carrick’s 419* for West of Scotland
against Chichester Priory Park in 1885.
Partnership
Chris and Dan Da Costa put on 205 for the 3rd
wicket. This is the highest Carlton partnership
for the 3rd wicket, beating by one run Preston
Mommsen (119*) and Jamie Kerr’s (109*)
unbeaten partnership of 204 in 2010 at
Titwood.
It is the 13th partnership for Carlton over 200
(including 3 prior to World War II). The
highest partnership of 262 was achieved last
season between Ruaraidh Main and Dan Da
Costa.
Highest Team Total
Carlton’s total of 420-3 is the highest First XI
total in the club’s history, easily eclipsing the
previous high of 388-5 against Stoneywood
Dyce in 2016.
It is the highest total scored at Grange Loan.
However it is not the highest in the EPL.
Watsonians, powered by Munsey’s innings
referred to above, got to 440-4. Nor is it the
highest by a Carlton XI, since the Third XI
scored 441-5 against LFAB 2 in 2010 in an
ESCA Division 5 match.
Victory Margin
The margin of victory of 237 runs is the
highest for Carlton’s First XI batting first.
Photos - previous Grange Loan record holders:
Ollie Rae 171* ; Gordon Drummond 169, Ali
Shah 207*
More Records

Text of this page
The pavilion was constructed just before the First World War and has subsequently been
developed and extended several times.
In 1902 the Scottish Counties Championship was inaugurated and Aberdeenshire won the
competition in its second year. They went on to win it 11 times. They dominated the
competition in the 1970s and 80s, winning it 6 times between 1975 and 1983. The
Championship disbanded with the founding of the Scottish National Cricket Leagues in 1996.
Aberdeenshire were also winners of the Scottish section of the National Club Cricket
Championship in 1981 and 82, known at the time as the John Haig Trophy, reaching the quarter
finals and losing to Scarborough the eventual winners on both occasions.
Aberdeenshire won the first Scottish National League in 1996, the SNCL North Division in 2004,
SNCL Division 1 in 2008, the SNCL Premier division in 2009 and the Eastern Premier League in
2014, when they also won the National Club Championship, beating Ayr by 5 wickets. They fell
out of the Eastern Premier League at the end of the 2019 season and have subsequently
competed in the Strathmore & Perthshire Union where they were runners-up in 2021.
Aberdeenshire have won the Scottish Cup twice, in 1996 and 2009. The Mannofield XI, in
effect Aberdeenshire’s Second XI, were a force in the Strathmore Union winning it on 4
occasions. They have won the Strathmore & Perthshire Union Premier Division 7 times.
In 2022 the club was home to the Northern Lights women's team who competed that season in
the Woman's Premier League.
Carlton in Aberdeen
Long before Edinburgh’s Carlton ventured north to Mannofield, there was a club of the same
name, established in the 1870s, who competed in the local leagues. They were Aberdeen
Junior League Champions in 1928, 29 and 30, and also winners of the Bon Accord Cup on
occasion, but did not survive World War 2
Carlton v Aberdeenshire
The forthcoming Scottish Cup
second round tie with
Aberdeenshire gives the
opportunity to look into the history
of contests between the clubs.
Aberdeenshire Cricket Club was founded in
April 1857. Within 2 seasons the team was
strong enough to entertain Grange CC and to
employ its first professional: Harry Lillywhite,
a member of the distinguished cricketing
family of the Victorian era whose members
also included the founders of the great sports
store at Piccadilly Circus. (There was a branch
of the store in Edinburgh’s Princes St until the
1980s). The club was an early member of the
fledgling Scottish Cricket Union.
With
the
support
of
prominent
local
businessmen, the club purchased Mannofield,
its current ground in 1890, its third location in
the city. The opening fixture was a match
against the Gentlemen of Edinburgh.

Text of this page
Carlton v Aberdeenshire
While Aberdeenshire first played Grange CC in
1859, it is uncertain when Carlton and
Aberdeenshire
first
crossed
swords.
NL
Stevenson refers to the fixture being revived
in 1906, when Carlton were victorious at
Mannofield, after dismissing the home side for
71, but there is no record of those earlier
encounters. He makes reference to some
subsequent matches - in 1908 he himself took
7 wickets for 35 to bring victory at Grange
Loan. In 1913 Carlton won by 8 wickets at
Grange Loan and there were further victories
in 1920 and 21. In 1921, Aberdeenshire were
the county champions and the defeat by
Carlton was their only loss of the season.
Carlton were dubbed by the newspapers
Scottish champions that season.
Following the Second World War there were
only 3 encounters between the clubs prior to
the SNCL. A drawn friendly in 1972 and cup
ties in 1982 and 1995, both of which went
Carlton’s way. Overall in this period, there
have been 39 matches between the clubs.
Carlton have won 19 and lost 12 with 4 draws
and 4 matches abandoned.
The most recent meeting was in the 2019 SC
at GL when Carlton won convincingly by 218
runs. Batting first, Rory McCann’s 119 (photo
below) helped the home team post 315 for 6
before the Carlton bowlers knocked the
visitors over for 97.
Four
years
previously
things
had
been
considerably closer with Carlton emerging the
narrowest of victors on DLS at Mannofield. A
century opening partnership between Hamish
Gardner and Fraser Watts was the foundation
of the victory.
Carlton pro Robin Singh was the first Carlton
player to score 100 against Aberdeenshire,
which he did in the 1995 cup tie. Cedric
English scored 2 centuries (108 in 2001 and
146 in 2010) and Rory McCann (see above),
Fraser Watts (103 in 2015) and Michael
Herdman (104 in 2017 - photo below also got
three figure scores against Aberdeenshire.
Mike Smith (above right - elder son of CC
Smith, see elsewhere in this issue) scored
120* for Aberdeenshire in the 1996 cup semi
final as Aberdeenshire demolished Carlton by
10 wickets at Grange Loan. They went on to
win the final.
Omar Ahmad (seen below) is the only Carlton
bowler to take 5 Aberdeenshire wickets. He
took 5 for 13 at GL in 2012 as Aberdeenshire
were skittled for 64. Ali Evans is Carlton’s
leading wicket taker against Aberdeenshire
with 24 scalps including 4-23 in 2018’s league
match at Grange Loan.

Text of this page
Aberdeenshire - Professionals
More recently, New Zealander Todd Astle was
pro at Mannofield in 2008 and 2009, playing a
big hand in the club’s double trophy success in
his second season. He subsequently played 5
Tests and 9 ODIs for NZ.
Without
doubt
the
most
celebrated
professional to have played at Aberdeenshire
is West Indian test star Rohan Kanhai who
spent 3 seasons in Aberdeen between 1958
and 1960. The West Indian connection at
Aberdeenshire was strong and Kanhai was the
third of a line of highly effective West Indian
professionals at Mannofield.
The first was Bermudan Alma Hunt, who had
been overlooked by the West Indies selectors
in 1933 (Bermuda not being affiliated to the
West Indian set up). He came to Scotland
and played eight seasons at Mannofield
between 1933 and 1947. During these years
he
plundered
8,190
runs,
including
22
centuries, and took 685 wickets. In the
process, he steered Aberdeenshire to their
first county championship in 24 years in 1946
and repeated the feat the following season
which was his last in Scotland.
In one legendary match for Aberdeenshire in
1939, against West Lothian Hunt took seven
wickets for 11 runs as West Lothian scored 48.
In response, Hunt opened the batting and
scored all 49 runs required to win, hitting two
sixes and eight boundaries in 25 minutes.
Hunt also became the first black cricketer to
represent Scotland, when he played two
games in August 1938; a draw against
Australia in a two-day game played at Forthill,
followed by a loss in a three-day game against
Yorkshire at Harrogate.
NL Stevenson described Hunt as a ‘genuine
personality… who played his cricket with a
captivating and refreshing zest, …and panther
like in the field like the great West Indian
contemporary [Leary] Constantine.’
He moved back to Bermuda, and became
heavily involved with administration of cricket
on the island. He became President of the
Bermuda Cricket Board in 1966, holding the
office for 18 consecutive years. As Bermuda's
delegate to the International Cricket Council
he was instrumental in advancing Associate
Cricket and instituting the ICC Trophy, which
Scotland won in 2005 and 2014 to qualify for
the World Cup. He was awarded the OBE in
1978 for services to sport in Bermuda.
Scotland made a lasting impression on Hunt,
he named his house in Bermuda “Mannofield”
after Aberdeenshire’s ground. He died in 1999.
Hunt (above) was followed at Mannofield by
his cousin and fellow Bermudan Nigel Hazel
(below) who went on to play for an extended
period at Strathmore CC where he led them to
the Scottish Cup victory in 1971. He died in
1996 at the age of 75.

Text of this page
By the time 22 year-old Rohan Kanhai arrived
at Mannofield he had already played Test
cricket having made test debut at Edgbaston
in 1957 and played throughout the series.
The subsequent three summers he spent at
Aberdeenshire where his batting dazzled - he
was at the time rated in the top 5 batsmen in
the world. He started off like he meant to
continue - scoring 101* in his first match (out
of 129-4) despite batting with a pulled
hamstring. In his first season he scored 1128
runs at an average of 104. It was not enough
to give Aberdeenshire the title - a drawn final
match allowed Perthshire to win the tightly
contested championship. In his final season
Kanhai scored a record aggregate of 766 runs
in the Scottish Counties Championship alone.
Sadly for Aberdeenshire, despise his box office
appeal, they could not afford to keep such a
star for a fourth season and Kanhai went to
Blackpool CC.
Kanhai subsequently spent 10 seasons at
Warwickshire where he scored over 11,000
runs at an average of 51.62.
Kanhai played 79 Tests for the West Indies
scoring 6227 runs at 47.53 with 15 centuries.
Following the retirement of Gary Sobers in
1973 he was briefly skipper.
Kanhai had many admirers. Perhaps the
greatest was the great West Indian cricket
writer C. L. R. James. “Kanhai,” he wrote,
“discovered, created, a new dimension in
batting. He had found his way into regions
Bradman never knew.”
Another admirer was Indian run machine Sunil
Gavaskar. He said that Kanhai was the
greatest batsman he had ever seen, and he
was so impressed by Kanhai that he called his
own son Rohan.
Rohan Kanhai
Before Kanhai could go on to excite regular
headlines like the below, Aberdeenshire had
to find somewhere for his to stay.

Text of this page
Mannofield has been Aberdeenshire’s home
since 1890. It was awarded ICC ODI status in
2008.
There have been 47 Scottish Cap matches at
Mannofield, The first was in 1930 against
Ireland, which Scotland won by 10 wickets,
Carlton and Greenock’s John Kerr scoring 89.
Scotland’s most recent match at Mannofield
was a loss in 2022 to USA in the final match of
a World Cricket League series. They had won
the previous matches against USA and UAE
In 2014 Scotland lost to England in a on-off
ODI which the weather reduced to 20 overs per
side. Carlton’s Ali Evans could do little to stop
the flow of runs from Alastair Cook, Ian Bell
and Eoin Morgan.
In 1971 Stenhousemuir’s Brian Hardie, soon to
move to Essex, scored 100 in each innings of a
drawn 3 day match against MCC.
In 2009 in a ODI against Canada Gordon
Drummond
took
4-41,
his
best
bowling
performance for Scotland. While Fraser Watts
scored 0 in that match, he had scored 101 in
the match between the teams the preceding
day, his top score for Scotland.
In 2008 New Zealand had an easy victory -
although Brendon McCullum was dismissed by
current Carlton coach Dewald Nel.
Mannofield
But
the
most
celebrated
match
in
Mannofield’s
history
was
in
1948
and
featured
the
last
appearance
of
Don
Bradman in Britain. He is seen below leading
his team out.
Bradman scored 123* in front of a reported
crowd of 10,000 as Australia coasted to an
easy innings victory. Carlton’s Tom Crosskey
was Scotland’s most successful batter with 49
in their first innings. Also in the Scotland side
was Aberdeenshire’s George Youngson who
took 3 wickets for 114 runs off 35 overs.
The Australians visited Mannofield on two
further occasions in 1956, when they had
another easy innings victory, and in 1964
when the match was drawn.

Text of this page
Towards the end of the 2016 season, Carlton travelled to Mannofield with
the championship in the balance. A win would secure the title. A
waterlogged ground meant that there was no play, leaving Carlton in an
unassailable position at the top of the league. A small celebration took
place.

Text of this page
There have been 2 significant players to have
played for both Carlton and Aberdeenshire
during their careers.
Aberdeen
born
RS
Clark
played
for
Aberdeenshire prior to the First World War. He
was selected to play for Scotland against
Ireland in 1912. Though he scored only 4 in
the first innings and 0 in the second - this was
a vital contribution, as Scotland won the
match by 3 runs.
Clark may be better known as the biologist on
Sir Ernest Shackleton’s ill-fated Antarctic
Expedition
in
1914-16.
Following
the
abandonment of their ship the Endurance in
the pack ice, he was among those left on
Elephant Island while Shackleton sailed to
South Georgia to seek help. They were
eventually rescued over 4 months later.
During the stay on Elephant Island Clark
managed to produce a primitive alcoholic
beverage from methylated spirit, sugar, water
and ginger which became known as "Gut Rot
1916" and was drunk with a toast to "Wives
and Sweethearts" on Saturdays.
He came to Carlton in 1921, often travelling
from Aberdeen where he became Director of
the Fisheries Research Station. NL Stevenson
described him as ‘a super batsman, so
effortless was his play.’ He was selected again
for Scotland in 1924, when he played two
matches against the touring South Africans.
He also played for Devon in the Minor
Counties
Championship
when
he
was
stationed in the South West.
RS CLARK, CC SMITH
Carlton and Aberdeenshire
Chris Smith, joined Carlton in 1961 and
quickly became established as the club’s key
all-rounder. He scored 6,168 runs and took
463 wickets. He was the club’s Best Bat four
years in succession between 1963 and 1966,
and subsequently in 1968. He was best
bowler in 1966. 71 and 73. He moved to
Aberdeen in 1973 to pursue his medical career
and became a key player for Aberdeenshire
until the mid-1980s. During his time at
Mannofield Aberdeenshire won the County
Championship 6 times. While Chris did not
score a century while at Carlton, he regularly
topped 3 figures at Aberdeenshire and his
132* in 1977 was the highest score by an
Aberdeenshire amateur.
While he was at Carlton Chris played against
Aberdeenshire in a friendly in 1972. He took
4-23 in the drawn match. In 1982 he played
for Aberdeenshire in a cup tie at Grange Loan.
He may not have enjoyed his return to his
previous hunting ground too much since he
scored only 1 and didn’t bowl as Carlton won
by 28 runs.
Chris retained a high affection for Carlton and
was a match sponsor for many years. He was
also awarded Honorary Life Membership.
Chris’s two sons Mike and Roddy became fine
cricketers themselves.
RS Clark in Carlton and Antarctic
gear
Report of CC
Smith’s last
match for
Carlton. It
was at Leith
Links as had
his first
league match
in Edinburgh
when he
played for
Edinburgh
University.

Text of this page
Chris Smith is seated far left in the
First XI photo for 1973, his last year
at Grange Loan
In August this year, Mannofield will be the venue for the ICC
U19 Women’s T20 World Cup Europe Qualifier, and the Scottish
Super 10 Franchise Event.

Text of this page
Aberdeenshire and Scotland
Colin Smith
The wicket-keeper batsman is
Aberdeenshire’s most capped
player with 182 caps between
1999 and 2009. In Scotland’s
2007 World Cup match against
Australia he top scored with 51.
Dallas Moir
The left arm spinner played 16
cap matches for Scotland and
went on to play First Class
cricket at Derbyshire. His best
return for Scotland best 4-43 v
Ireland and for Derbyshire he
took 6-60 v Notts. While at
Aberdeenshire, his 3-8 off 11
overs was central to
Aberdeenshire’s cup final victory
by 2 runs over Clydesdale in
1986.
George Youngson
had 17 Scottish caps
between 1947 and 1955
In 1950 against Ireland at
Perth in 1950 he took
7-42 in the first innings
and 4-77 in the second
innings.
Willie Donald
He played 58 cap
matches for Scotland
between 1978 and 1987
and was President of
Cricket Scotland in
2018-19. His brother
Richard Donald played for
both Carlton and
Aberdeenshire.

Text of this page
There have been a few changes to the GL bar
both behind the scenes and front of house.
Very sadly Susanna won’t be behind the bar
this season as she now has a job in London and
we couldn’t persuade her to come back every
weekend. Although she has assured me she
will be back as a customer when watching Zaki
play !
Grace Simpson will be working most weekends
with Leo Crutchley and Callum Glass also doing
shifts. You might see Al Murray or John Beattie
serving after a Sunday match - and if anyone
else would like to be trained to do a volunteer
shift after a match, please let Kerryknow.
If you have been at the bar since the start of
the season (and if not, why not ?) then you’ll
have noticed that we have a new beer on tap -
Ice Breaker IPA. We have also expanded the
variety of drinks at Carlton Cocktail Corner with
the new Grange Loan Spritz one to try. As
always we have a large variety of soft and non
alcoholic drinks including Jump Ship Lager and
IPA - a big thank you to them for continued
sponsorship of the club.
Social events are a big part of Carlton. Not
only are they a great way to mix with other
members but they bring valuable revenue into
the club. Expenditure on the ground and the
nets has to be paid for and by coming along to
support events at the club, you can do your bit
- and have a good time too!

Text of this page
Catch Me if You Can!
Epic Run Chases
There was great excitement at Grange Loan at
the start of the month as Carlton 2 chased
down
Drummond
Trinity’s
apparently
unassailable 262 to give them an important
victory in the first skirmish of their Division 1
campaign. All the batters contributed, with
Ben
D’Ulisse’s
67
and
Charles
Buchanan-Smith’s
51
ensuring
that
they
stayed in touch with the run rate. Even so 12
was needed off the last over. Cometh the
hour…… skipper Charles Stronach’s mighty six
off the second ball brought the victory within
grasp and with 2 needed off 3 balls, misfield
mayhem allowed Max D’Ulisse to scramble the
necessary runs for victory (photo below). It
was said after the match that the biggest
cheer came at Goldenacre when the moment
of victory interrupted Arun Pillai’s post mortem
on a disappointing day for the First XI.
Awesome as this chase was, it was not the
highest in the Second’s history. In 1991 they
faced up to chase 263 at Inverleith against
StewMel 2. Things got off to a poor start and
they were soon 11-3. But an unbeaten stand
of 253 between Chris Kear (140*) and Paul
Bailey (90) (nb this is not the same P Bailey
who has recently featured in the 5th XI) took
them home to a momentous victory in 41.5
overs.
The First XI’s highest chase was in 2009
against
Uddingston
at
Bothwell
Castle.
Uddingston put 271-5 on the board built on
Australian Tom Plant’s 108. When Bryn Lockie
was third out with the score on 96, a victory
looked a distant prospect. But a partnership
of 165 between skipper Cedric English (143*)
and Ross Lyons (80) brought Carlton within
sight and the secured the victory in the 49th
over.
English quite liked the Uddingston attack - the
next season he scored 148* against them at
Grange Loan. This was the highest of the 18
centuries he scored for Carlton.
The Third XI scored 237-3 in 44.2 overs to
overtake Dunfermline Knights 2 at McKane
Park in 2011. An unbeaten 100 for Aravind
Srinivasan and 98 for Seb Rae.
Younger members celebrate a great 3rd chase.
The Fourth XI went to Largo for the final
match of the 2018 season needing victory to
secure their promotion slot. Things did not go
quite to plan when the home team racked up
234-5 off their 40 overs. But when Paul
Kentish was was dismissed for a magnificent
140, 12 were needed off 4 overs and to
youngsters Euan Burgess and Rua McIntyre
were able to take the 4s home.
For the Fifth XI, Fergus Foley’s 80* and
skipper Keith Murray’s 58 were the basis of
their 195-4 against Drummond Trinity 5 at
Grange Loan in 2022. The visitors’ innings
had seen the unusual sight of James Stronach
bowling - he took 3-26.
Fergus reaches his 50 in the Fifth’s Great Chase -
Highlight on this link
In 2022 Carlton's women chased down 172-8
to secure a momentous victory against the
Northern Lights at Mannofield. Sam Haggo’s
61 off 32 balls being the top score after Gabby
Fontenla’s 4-26 had done much to slow the
home momentum.

Text of this page
Carlton teams have also suffered by seeing a seemingly impregnable total chipped away. In
the final match of the 2004 season against Ferguslie, the First XI put 281-6 on the board, with
151 from Fraser Watts, and might have felt confident in defending it. But 100 from the late
Con DeLange supported by 54 from Majid Haq gave the Paisley side a 4 wicket victory in the
last over. Ferguslie were just pipped by Clydesdale for the title that season.
The Second XI, with Peter Swan and Craig Marshall each scoring 94 amassed 261-7 against
Watsonians 2 in 2009 at Grange Loan, only to lose by 3 wickets. Watsonians were generous
enough to acknowledge later in a message on the ESCA website the sporting nature of the
match in which Carlton gave Watsonians a substitute fielder throughout the match when they
suffered a late call up to the First XI and and a subsequent injury during the match.
The Third XI have twice been chased down for 177. In 2018 it was not enough against
Edinburgh South who overtook it with 1 wicket to spare. Dunfermline made an easier job of it
in 2022, losing only 4 wickets as they chased down Carlton’s total which had owed much to 71
from Paul Kentish and 51* from the late Amit Bij.
Scores of 200 are not the norm for the Fourth XI, so going to tea with 243-6 on the board
(thanks to 63 from Leigh Kasperek and 58 from Craig Everett) against Teuchters at Grange
Loan in 2010 left them reasonably confident. However the visitors had other ideas and,
despite a hattrick from Neil Browning, they reached the unlikely total with one ball to spare.
In 2018 the Fifth XI’s 151-3 (Keith Murray 79*) against Musselburgh was not good enough to
avoid a narrow 1 wicket defeat.
In 2012 the Women failed to defend 94-3 in a 20 over match with George Watson’s.
Coming Soon
To Grange Loan
Fri 7 June - Pizza Geeks
Sat 15 June - Social Event by Carlton
Women - can they better last year’s Bingo
Night?
Fri 20 July - Pizza Geeks

Text of this page
I swapped the six months of the Scottish
winter
to
play
cricket
down
under
in
Melbourne; it’s been one of the most exciting,
challenging and rewarding experiences of my
cricket career and life so far.
After completing my undergraduate studies
last year I was offered the opportunity to
play as the overseas for Port Melbourne CC in
the Victorian Sub-district Cricket Association –
regarded as the second-strongest league in
Victoria. With nothing planned for the British
winter, accepting a deal to travel halfway across
the world to play cricket was a no brainer!
Upon landing in Australia there was no rest,
as I was taken for a tour of the club by the
president and coach before joining the team for
training in the evening. The club is one of the
oldest and biggest in Victoria, with a rich
history and an unbelievable ground with many
of its past players going on to play first-class
cricket. Similar to Carlton, the squad was
comprised of young talented players with many
in their early twenties, making the environment
enjoyable on and off the field.
Following a meeting with the first team coach, I
was made aware that the club had only moved
up to subdistrict level a couple of years ago and
had been struggling with the jump in standard,
only winning one of their games last season
even with the help of Essex’s Feroze Kushi as
their overseas scoring over 400 runs. After the
first
three
games,
despite
some strong individual
performances
from
myself and other teammates, we were yet to
have our first win of the season. However, in
the fourth game of the season, the team put
together
a
comprehensive
win,
beating
Moorabbin by 73 runs. From then on the team
started
to
click,
putting
in
some
solid
performances
and
going
on
to
win
seven from our last ten games. We ended up
closely missing out on finals, however, the club
was more than happy with the way the team
performed compared to previous years. I hope
they can carry on the momentum we gained
from the end of the season and aim for finals
next year.
Lewis after his 6/69 off 26 overs in 35
degree heat. Two balls had to be used after
the first Kookaburra's seam started to split.
LEWIS O’DONNELL
A Successful Winter
Down Under

Text of this page
Personally, I couldn’t have asked for much
more from a cricketing perspective. I ended
the season with 39 wickets at an average of
14.44, finishing second in the league wicket
tally
after
being
top
until
the
penultimate game only
for
someone
to
take 9 wickets in an innings and knock me off
the top spot!
A particular highlight was a game against
finalists Ormond, where I took 6/69 off 26
overs, bowling 16 overs in my second spell.
With the bat I also put together some strong
performances, especially in the white ball
games scoring 213 runs at an average of
30.43, including a half-century against a
bowling attack including ex-Tasmania and Big
Bash bowler Andrew Fekete, taking our side
from 79-6 to 8-186 in a tightly fought game in
which we narrowly came out on top. At the
end of the season I was picked for the VSDCA
team of the year and awarded the Port
Melbourne
1st
grade
bowling
and
club
champion awards.
Outside of playing for Port Melbourne, I was
part of the International Cricket Programme,
where I received 1:1 and group coaching.
The programme offered two sessions a week
with a real focus on individual skills and the
mental side of the game, a nice contrast to the
team sessions run by Port Melbourne.
Under the tutelage of Dimi Mascarenhas, Bobby
Quiney and Ian Holland, I feel like my game
has steadily improved. As well as improving my
cricket, the programme allowed me to meet
other overseas cricketers and form some good
friendships.
I was also fortunate enough to play some
games
for
The Crusaders; an
organisation
similar to the MCC with the likes of Glenn
Maxwell and Will Sutherland having previously
represented
the
organisation.
It
was a
great opportunity to play some more cricket at
fantastic grounds with good players, in total I
played four matches for The Crusaders against
some of the local schools and cricket Australia
staff.
Overall, the experience of spending the winter
in Australia has been amazing and I am
excited to get back to Carlton for what should
be an exciting and successful summer.

Text of this page
DAVID PONNIAH (POON) RECALLS THE SCOTTISH
CRICKET TEAM OF THE YEAR
Between 1985 and 1996 Poon played 123 League and Cup matches and 30 T20 matches for
Carlton scoring a total of 3243 runs. His top score was 110, scored in a drawn match at
Kirkcaldy in 1987. He was Best Bat in season 1986 when he scored 625 League and Cup runs
at 44.64.
Prior to coming to Grange Loan, David played at Stenhousemuir. For Stenhousemuir against
Carlton his highest score was 96* in a drawn match at the Tryst in 1984. He was in the
Stenhousemuir side which lost the Masterton final to Carlton in 1982.
His best for Carlton against Stenhousemuir was 80* in the Masterton semi-final in 1994.
Carlton won the final against Watsonians.

Text of this page
1988 - The Glory Year
One of the strange and annoying aspects of
playing cricket at Grange Loan was the
presence and proximity of the Carlton Buffties
(def; a Buffty is an old and eccentric
academic), seated on the hill expressing their
views on most aspects of life, and in particular
on cricket. 36 years later, I am now a Buffty
and I thought it is my turn to comment and
maybe encourage the present cohort of
cricketers, to enjoy the game of cricket and
appreciate that winning is not the ultimate
goal.
At the outset it must be stated, if not widely
known, that in 1988 the Club was celebrating
125 years and incredibly won the East League
for the first time and further won the
Masterton
Trophy
(presented
by
Mrs
Masterton, the Club Patron). It was an
excellent and rewarding year for Carlton.
Hence, with the aid of the current buffties I
gathered records of the year 1988. I thought
it might be interesting to further delve into
these records, players and their performances
without actually naming individuals. It must
be always remembered that Cricket is a team
game
characterised
by
individual
performances, and overall success is only
through the performance of all members of
that team.
There
were
about
20
individuals
who
represented the Club in 1988, and it could be
fairly said that 10 players played a significant
part
in
the
performance
of
the
team.
Professional paid cricketers from around the
world were permitted to play in many of the
leagues
in
Scotland,
including
the
East
League.
Carlton
chose
not
to
hire
a
professional
for
a
number
of
reasons,
including
the
enormous
cost.
The
Club
eventually benefited from this decision,
with all the amateur players having the
opportunity to contribute to the success of the
team, without the professional dominating the
proceedings.
While many of the cricket clubs in Scotland
drew their players from local schools, Carlton
benefitted from players joining from outside
this group, and the 1988 team matched this
profile of players. Few of the players came
through the ranks of the club, and the
majority were from outside Edinburgh. We had
players from the Borders, Dunfermline, South
Africa, Ceylon, Aberdeen and even Glasgow.
Interestingly the professions covered farmers,
teachers
(including
a
trainee
priest),
academics, racing drivers and some others
with
dubious
activities.Unusually,
despite
being in close proximity to the Universities
there was an absence of undergraduates.
Much has been said and written about the
ages of the players of that year, ranging from
the twenties, thirties, forties and even a fifty.
It certainly was a motley crew and rarely
brilliant on the field, and even less brilliant at
practices. Jim Love of Yorkshire and England
was a blunt talker, likened the Carlton Team to
Dad’s Army, as in the sitcom. We certainly
looked it and even had our own Mainwaring
and a Pyke, but Jim was certainly not happy
when his Heriot’s side were convincingly
beaten!
Just
as
an
overview
of
the
individual
performances, two of the batsman scored
almost half of the runs during the season, with
remainder of the runs coming from four other
batsmen. These statistics may not be unusual
but the bowling statistics are! Two bowlers,
the oldest (50+) and the youngest (20+),
delivered
50%
of
the
overs
and
not
surprisingly gathered in excess over half of the
total number of the wickets.
The club won the league in a convincing
manner. The rules and the scoring/points
system in the East League was tortuous and
complicated and does not warrant analysis.
What is significant is that Carlton had an
overall win percentage of 73%, with none of
the other teams even reaching 65%. It was a
wet season with soft surfaces to play on and it
is not surprising that the bowlers dominated
the game. This was also true for Carlton. The
final accolade, I personally would give is to the
oldest member of the team who bowled
brilliantly in 1988, but unfortunately is not
with us any more.
Carlton 1988
League and Cup Averages
R Marsden 574 runs @ 41.00
H Parker 559 runs @ 31.06
D Ponniah 381 runs @ 25.40
R Swan 364 runs @26.00
G Inness 46 wkts @11.17
J Govan 34 wkts@24.54
A Macpherson 27 wkts@21.67
R Dickinson 19 wkts@25.53

