Issue 48
· South of the border
Fantasy Bob has been busy compiling another action packed edition of “The Arrow”. In this month’s issue there is a report from the U13s expedition south of the border on their extended ECB cup run. Also in this edition is the long and complicated history of games between Carlton and Stew Mel in their various guises – including a piece from Rob Thornton and a match report from Cheeky out of the archives. In addition, Joe Griffin tells of the time he played against a rock superstar; Martin Firth reports on the Junior Sixes; Tom Simpson reviews the Primary School team’s season and much, much more.

Text of this page
The Newsletter of Carlton Cricket Club
9 August 2022 Issue 48
SOUTH OF THE BORDER
The last couple of weeks have seen
successive volleys of Carlton’s Junior
Arrows fired over Hadrian’s Wall in the
ECB Under 13s Cup. Intrepid reporters
Kelly and Jon Foley followed the
excitements of the cup run, first to
Newcastle and then to Neston CC on the
Wirrall, pictured above. Read their
account inside.
CARLTON IS A CLUB FOR EVERYONE
Link to Carlton’s Statement on Changing the
Boundaries - Plan4Sport’s report on CricketScotland

Text of this page
On, then, to
the
Northern
Region Finals
Day
on
26
July - venue
as last year:
Neston
Cricket
Club
in
the
Wirral...great
facilities, just
a bit tough to
get to from
Scotland!
SOUTH OF THE BORDER
Having retained the Scottish Under 13
Cup, Carlton were drawn in the next
round
against
a
strong
South
Northumberland CC requiring a trip to
Newcastle. Fog on the Tyne? No chance,
it was a blisteringly hot day.
Winning the toss and batting, we set a
steady total of 110 against a strong
bowling attack. John Gill fell to an
extraordinary catch at short mid off (or
"at Keith" to most of the juniors who have
played
for
the
5s)
bringing
James
Stronach
to
the
crease
early.
A
swashbuckling 30 from James led to
retiral, with Hamish Foley joining the
dogged Tom Hathorn to build the score.
When Tom finally fell for 23 in the 18th
over, in strode Freddie Charman for the
final flourish. Our last three overs brought
valuable runs, with Hamish F and Fred
stealing ones and twos with incredible
confidence - almost telepathy at times.
But would 110 be enough?! It felt like 20
short to the hardened cricket experts on
the boundary - but what do we know?
Our fielding innings was probably the best
we have seen from this group and was the
difference between the sides. Every catch
taken (not going to use the obvious
cricket cliche), no overthrows gifted and
every wicket (James Deakin taking 3,
Finlay Thompson 2, and Aadi Khadse,
Hamish Turner and Hamish F one each)
celebrated as a full team. Great to watch
and credit to the spirit in this squad.
South
Northumberland,
despite
their
obvious talents up top, were simply blown
away. Once their talisman was felled, they
had no answer and succumbed to 86 in
their 20 overs. Start the car and get back
over the border!
The squad’s reward for the win against
SNCC was an overnighter....TOUR! A very
decent party made the trip with the squad
-
Mums,
Dads,
Sisters,
Brothers,
Grandparents...no WAGS (just yet). The
Red Fox in Thornton Hough was our return
venue for dinner and didn't disappoint -
and
nor
did
the
team,
behaving
impeccably while clearing plates for fun.
Finally to bed, and recharging batteries for
the big day.
We were guaranteed two matches, facing
Sandiacre Town from Derbyshire first in
the semifinal.
Win toss, bat. James S and Hamish F
started brightly enough, but when James
fell to decent pace bowling, Ollie Stones
strode to the wicket - freshly tanned and
full of confidence. Ollie set the tone with
an unbeaten 30 (off 18), with Aadi and
Hamish T then chipping in with 29 (off 33)
and 24 (off 12) respectively. A busy
cameo from Tom H with the tail got us to
135 for 8 in our 20 overs. That would take
some chasing!

Text of this page
Sandiacre set out with intent,
but with Hamish F removing
both openers, the wickets
began to tumble - and were
shared around. 8 bowlers
used, wickets for 5 (Hamish
F, James D, Ollie, Tom and Aadi), three
catches and a stumping for James S.
Sandiacre Town all out for 88 in 18.5 overs
- Aadi taking three wickets in 0.5 overs to
finish proceedings - another awesome team
effort. On to the final!
As the sun rose higher for
the final, so did the standard
of cricket as we met a very
strong side from Whitburn CC
in County Durham.
The boys all admitted they had rarely faced
bowling this fast and consistent before -
Whitburn were a cut above. Only two of
our batters made it to double figures - an
outstanding 30 retired (again) from the
day's golden bat Ollie - and a gritty 16
from Hamish F. John G was very unlucky to
be
run
out
by
a
deflection
at
the
non-striker's end for 7....gutted not the
word. Everyone else ducked and weaved,
but in the end 88 off 20 was going to need
something special to defend.
In the end Whitburn were too good and
were deserved winners. An excellent
bowling spell from Harrison (3-fer) and a
smart run out from John G were not
enough...Whitburn chased down the total
in the 15th over and took the spoils.
Much to the delight of their raucous
travelling support...who were definitely
going to need a few stops on the way
home.
All in all, this quiver of under 13 Arrows
(and we mean all of them) should be
proud
of
a
superb
achievement
in
reaching the last 8 in the ECB Cup
nationwide - for the second year in a
row.
Third time lucky anyone???

Text of this page
It was the best of times. The dawn of a new
millennium and I was living my best life as a
young diplomat based at the British Embassy
in Paris. A city centre apartment on the Rue
de Berri; a stroll down the rue du Faubourg
Saint-Honoré to work in one the most
prestigious Embassies in Europe, supposedly
requisitioned by the Duke of Wellington
himself after Waterloo, usually picking up a
croissant on the way, to keep me going until
the 90 minute lunchbreak; or a working lunch
at one of the 8th arrondisement’s excellent
brasseries. And, er, cricket!?
Yes, it seemed like an unexpected bonus to
discover that the Embassy had a thriving
cricket team, its origins presumably back in
those post Waterloo days, but nurtured by
enthusiasm and two actual grass nets at the
back of the Embassy grounds adjoining the
Champs-Élysées itself.
CRICKET
WITH THE
STARS
You’ve got to move
like Jagger
Joe Griffin
The matches numbered around 6 a year, and
were scheduled around France, in contrast to
the purely Paris based inter-Embassy football
league where every week brought a different
international on the dusty football pitches of
the Bois de Vincennes.
Anyway. I particularly looked forward to the
game in Saumur in the Loire Valley. The older
hands spoke in hushed tones of the beautiful,
green surroundings. The hospitality of the
local vineyard owner and #3 batsman. And,
in the hushest of hush tones, the possible
participation of one of the most famous men
on Earth.
The day of glory arrived, and we drove down
in convoy to Saumur on a beautiful May day.
As we piled out of our cars at the ground, we
soaked up the scene of French bucolic
harmony, and spotted the oppo waiting for us
around the boundary rope. Scanning the
slightly irregular looking collection of folk, one
skinny, raffish looking character stood out
above all. As we approached, greetings were
offered and hands stuck out. ‘Thierry….’ ‘PJ…’,
‘Alex..’, and then, “Hi, I’m Mick.”
It was true. This was actually happening.
Mon dieu.
Cont’d over/
On the Loire -
Jagger and Griffin
circled

Text of this page
Anyway, as far as the cricket was concerned,
Stewart hit a great knock and went past 50
easily, dispatching the ball to all corners.
However, his nemesis then approached, as
Mick – looking a little dishevelled if I’m
honest – was thrown the ball to bowl. Now,
it’s safe to say that the man has had a
successful life. He’s a global talent. He is
richer than Louis Vuitton. Hell, the only
reason he was playing for Saumur was
because he owned the actual castle down the
road – just one of his houses. But, whisper
it, he’s not a great cricketer. Stewart tucked
into the kind of buffet we were looking
forward to later at the vineyard and hit the
first three balls for 4. Surely, the ton itself
was on? However, Bertie mistimed pie #4
and was caught on the boundary! BERTIE ct
Thierry b Jagger 62. Stewie slank off the
pitch to the applause of the “crowd” and
uttered in his beautiful Brummie accent, the
now immortal line, “Well, if he wasn’t famous
before, he is now.”
I don’t remember the rest of the game, other
than the West Indian bodyguard scoring
even more than Bertie, and losing at least
one ball. Presumably Mick handpicked him
for just this kind of occasion…. He’s no fool.
To conclude, I’m happy to say that we did
adjourn to the vineyard, where Thierry
served us red wine straight from the vats out
of a watering can. Good times were had.
Mick stayed for a bit and then headed back
to his place for a rest, or to put an entry in
his diary about an enjoyable game of cricket
and his encounter with a future Carlton 5th XI
dilettante. He was a top bloke who loved his
cricket. Which is about one the nicest things
you can say about anyone.
/Cont’d
I was so star struck I didn’t really notice the
bodyguard at first. But he, like Mick, seemed
super friendly, if built like the proverbial
maison de merde en brique. It was only as
we exchanged a few words, that I picked up
the unmistakable lilt of a Caribbean, you
might say, West Indian accent. Uh oh.
The match itself was good fun, and how could
you not enjoy fielding in the middle of a field
in the Loire valley, with the sun on your back?
You can’t always get what you want, as the
man himself sang, but this seemed perfect.
The
highlight
of
the
game
was
a
swashbuckling
innings
from
our
resident
Brummie, Stewart Bertie. Now, Bertie just the
week before had nearly started World War 3 in
one of those inter Embassy football matches
against the Turkish Embassy. That really is a
story for another day, not least as this is a
family newsletter, and it’s a little blue. But it
is a great story.
Cricketing Rolling Stones - publicity shot from 1968
Jagger (back rt) in his school cricket team age 13
Jagger with Charlie Watts and others at CWC
Final 2019

Text of this page
Carlton v Stewart’s
Melville
A series looking at the history
of Carlton’s City rivalries.
With thanks to Alan Veitch for additional information
As would be expected from the timeline
summarised
above,
Carlton’s
oldest
relationship with the ‘Stew-Mel family’ is
with the Royal High branch.
NL Stevenson makes reference in his
history of Carlton to a match against
‘the High School’ in 1865, in which
Carlton dismissed them for 29, then
proceeded to score 165-8. But there is
no reference to this match in the more
comprehensive records for RHSFP found
on the Stewart’s Melville website. The
first match recorded there between
Carlton and Royal High School FP was in
1869 at Royal High’s then ground at
Holyrood (see map below).
Carlton
were
victorious,
dismissing
RHSFP for 79 in response to their 142.
Regular fixtures followed right up until
RH’s merger with Stewart’s Melville.
In all, 96 matches were played between
the clubs with 46 victories for Carlton,
26 for RH and 24 draws.
The present Stewart’s Melville Cricket
Club is the product of a number of
mergers over the years. There are
therefore 3 strands of Carlton’s history
bound up in their relations with this
club.
Daniel Stewart’s College FP CC (also
known
in
early
records
as
Stewartonians) was founded in 1877.
Melville College FP had started life as as
Edinburgh
Institution
FP
and
was
founded in 1872. The Edinburgh
Institution
for
Languages
and
Mathematics
changed
its
name
to
Melville College in 1937 and the club
followed suit.
In 1972 Daniel Stewart’s FP merged
with Melville College FP, reflecting the
amalgamation
of
the
schools,
to
become Stewart’s Melville FP CC.
In 1996, Stewart’s Melville, by now an
open club like all other FP clubs,
merged with Royal High to become
SMRH.
SMRH revised its name to Stewart’s
Melville CC in 2018.
SMRH.
Royal High School
FP CC had been
founded
in
1861
and was one of the
oldest of the many
FP
clubs
in
Scotland. The FP
designation
was
dropped when the
club became open
in the 1970s.
Royal High crest
Early Fixtures

Text of this page
Carlton
first
played
Edinburgh
Institution FP in 1877 at Grange Loan,
Carlton scoring 91 to EI’s 33. According
to the press report ‘The Institution
team having been newly formed this
result was not altogether unexpected.’
Fixtures were irregular between the
clubs. (Poor results led to EI’s demise in
1883 but it was reincarnated in 1899).
In the 1960s, Melville College FP was
one of the stronger clubs in the East of
Scotland, winning the then East League
and the Masterton.
Between 1877 and 1972 there were
only 32 matches between Carlton and
Edinburgh Institution/Melville FP, of
which Carlton won 16, EI 10 and 6
draws.
Carlton’s
first
match
with
Daniel
Stewart’s FP (Stewartonians) was at
Grange Loan in the opening game of
the 1888 season, which ended with the
scores tied on 62. Only 2 bowlers on
either side took wickets, and Carlton
conceded no extras.
Press report of the first ever Carlton v
Edinburgh Institution match in 1877. ‘...this
result was not altogether expected. ..the
heavy rains which fell during the club’s
innings made their score smaller than it
might otherwise have been.’
Rt: Press report of the first ever Carlton v
Stewartonians match in 1888 ‘McBeth and
Carruthers now troubled the bowlers and
although a change was made it did not bring
about the desired separation’.
This was Stewartonian’s best result
against Carlton for many years. It
took them until 1959 to secure their
first victory - although, as with Melville
College FP, fixtures were less than
regular. In 39 matches between 1888
and 1972 Carlton lost only 2.
The newly merged Stewart’s Melville
CC’s first outing against Carlton was in
1973. A Masterton tie at Grange Loan
finished in a home victory by 5
wickets. SM fared no better in the East
League fixture later in the season,
losing by 80 runs.
SM never achieved victory against
Carlton in the years before the merger
with RH.
The newly established SMRH first faced
Carlton at Inverleith in 1997. The
match was drawn. In all there were 12
fixtures between Carlton and SMRH, of
which Carlton won 8.
SM have done no better in the years
since 2019 when they reverted to their
original name. Overall in the 50
fixtures from 1973 prior to this season
they have won only 6. Carlton have
won 33.

Text of this page
RHSFP
In 1908 Carlton scored 368-4 against Royal
High School FPs with George Jupp scoring
202*. Jupp (see NL44) obviously enjoyed
the RHSFP bowling - he had taken 137* off
them in the previous season’s match in
which he also took 7-46. In all, 5 of Jupp’s
24 centuries for Carlton were scored against
RHSFP.
In 1904 Carlton dismissed RHSFP for 8, the
lowest total to which they have ever
restricted their opposition.
Stewart’s FP
Against Daniel Stewart’s FP, Carlton’s
highest score is 182-4 in 1907. Their
lowest is 41 in 1889, remarkably this was
a winning score since Stewart’s were
dismissed for 28 in reply. Early matches
were notable for low scores - the
following year Stewart’s were dismissed
for 22.
Stewart’s Melville
Carlton’s 314-7 in August 2021 is their
highest score against SM. Their lowest
was in 1973 when they made only 153 at
Inverleith.
Hugh Parker has the highest score, 92*,
made at Inverleith in 1990 while Ali
Evans’ 6-19 in the match at GL in 2021 is
the best bowling.
SMRH
Carlton’s highest score against SMRH was
in the 2010 Scottish Cup tie at Grange
Loan when they amassed 307-7 with Pete
Deakin top scoring on 96*, which is also
Carlton’s highest innings.
The best bowling performance against
SMRH was also in the Scottish Cup, 7
years later at Inverleith, when Michael
Herdman and Ali Evans were too much
for the home batters who were dismissed
for
22,
5
of
which
were
extras.
Herdman’s return was 5-2-7-5 which
included a hat-trick is the best return.
Chayank Gosain has most wickets against
SMRH with 13.
Jamie Kerr’s 8 appearances against SMRH
are the most by a Carlton player.
In more recent
times,
Carlton
scored 248 for 5
in June 1991 at
Grange Loan.
Hugh
Parker’s
109
at
Jock’s
Lodge in 1985 is
the highest score
by
as
Carlton
batter, and the
only
century,
against RH(SFP)
in the post war
period.
Highs and Lows
Richard Dickinson (l) is
the top wicket taker
against SM with 19 and
Ali Evans’ 6-19 in 2021
is the best bowling.
Richard Dickinson - 344
wkts in 253 Carlton
appearances. Best Bowler
1983
1985
Hugh Parker - 109 v RH, 92* v
SM
Alun
Davies
has the most
appearances
against RHSFP
with 27 - not
surprisingly he
also
has
the
most
wickets
with
41.
Davies
also
has
the most appearances against SM with 7,
and against Stewart’s with 10.
The best bowling against RH was by George
Innes who took 8-25 at Jock’s Lodge in
June 1982 - his career best return.

Text of this page
Carlton Women v Stewart’s Melville
Carlton Women first played against a Stewart’s Melville team in 2018 in the Women’s
Premier League, losing by 29 runs to the then combined Edinburgh South/Stewart’s
Melville side. That partnership, which was developed by Katie McGill (see p11), is no
longer in existence - SM now compete in the Premier League while ES continue to
provide important opportunities at the introduction and developmental level. This
season both SM and ES, now in partnership with MDAFS, have competed in the
Women’s Challenger League. In 8 fixtures between Carlton and SM women first teams
prior to this season, Carlton have won 3. Carlton and SM face each other again on 21
August in the semi-final of the Beyond Boundaries T20 Cup.
The first fixture played by Carlton Women’s 2nd XI this season was against SM.
In 2019 Heather Tait (below left) scored 101* at Inverleith, although it was not enough
to win the match. Best bowling is by Zaara Dancu (below rt) who took 4-22 in the
Scottish Cup tie in August 2021.
Edinburgh Institution/Melville
College FP
In
1896
Carlton
bowled
Edinburgh
Institution out for 9, NL Stevenson taking 6
wickets for 5 runs.
Fixtures with Edinburgh Institution were
regular only during the 1920s. Carlton
scored 283-4 in 1921, CS Paterson (see
NL44) scoring 138*, before dismissing
them for 51. Similar results followed in the
next 2 years with Carlton topping 200 and
EI failing to make 100. Carlton’s lowest
score of 40 had been in 1880.
Fixtures resumed in the 1950s when the
club had changed its name to Melville
College
FPs
and
were
an
altogether
stronger outfit. Carlton could only muster
41 in 1962 and their top score was 148 in
1954. No Carlton player scored a century
against Melville in this period.
Carlton Lottery
Recent Winners
Angus Mair
Richard Allardice
Archie Robertson
Lynne Whitaker
lottery@carltoncc.co.uk

Text of this page
Melville FP CC was the first winner of the Masterton Cup in
1964, beating Royal High School FP in the Final. They had also
beaten Stewart’s FP in an earlier round. Melville FP won the
trophy again in 1966.
Carlton did not enter the Masterton Trophy until 1968. It took
them until 1974 to win the trophy, which they did by beating
Royal High School FP at Ferryfield, the ground of Melville
College FP.
Victory actually took two attempts. In the first encounter
Carlton had made 106-7 off their 25 overs; as the rain fell,
RHSFP seemed well placed on 65-3 after 17 overs but an injury
to Carlton’s bowler Richard Dickinson at the start of the 18th
over led to play being abandoned suggesting the ground had
become dangerously slippery.
Two nights later, with Dickinson restored to fitness, Carlton
made 113-4 - thanks to Fraser Dall’s 60*. RHSFP were 98-8 at
the close of their innings and skipper Alun Davies could hold the
trophy aloft for the first of the 15 times Carlton have won it.
It took Carlton another 8 years to win the trophy a second time.
In 1982 they beat Stenhousemuir at Myreside.
Fraser Dall - 3282
runs in 129
matches for
Carlton. He won
best bat in 5
seasons
Some Masterton History

Text of this page
A.S.
Cairns
started
with
Edinburgh
Institution, playing subsequently for Leith
Caledonian and, during the last years of his
career, at Carlton - the photo below shows
him in the Carlton First XI in 1911.
Watsonians, Drumpellier and West of
Scotland and was then at Carlton in 1996
and 1997, winning Carlton's Best Batter
Award in 1997.
Over the years there have been a number
of players who have played for both
Carlton and one of the SM family. Here
are some of the better known.
English c Gosain
b Ahmad 67 -
congratulations
after the 2014
match.
A.S. Cairns was a fast
bowler and sound bat who
represented
Scotland
8
times,
captaining
them
twice. His debut match
was in 1891 against a
Gloucestershire
side
captained by W.G. Grace.
Prior to becoming Carlton’s
professional in 192 Tom
Crosskey (see NL44) had
been coach at the Royal
High School.
Alistair Storie had played
for Northamptonshire and
Warwickshire
before
becoming
Stewart’s
Melville
professional
in
1989.
He
represented
Scotland 33 times.
After
leaving
Stewart’s
Melville, he played for
After 14 outstanding years at Grange
Loan, Cedric English became Director of
Cricket at SMRH in 2013 and 2014. He
never lead his new side to victory over his
old friends - his best score was 67 at GL
in 2014. He won SM’s best bat Tankard in
both seasons.
Stew-Mel Royal High - Players
Katie McGill was
a key member of
Carlton Women’s
sides
between
2012 and 2017
and
played
regularly, for the
3rd and 4th XIs.
Katie then took on on a player/coach role
at Edinburgh South CC. She was highly
instrumental
in
developing
women’s
cricket
through
a
partnership
with
Stewart’s Melville. She continues to play
for SM Women and is an important
member of the Scotland Women’s team.
Katie completed her PhD in material
science in 2021 and is now Regional
Development
Officer
East
at
CricketScotland.
Bryn Lockie (rt
in 1991) spent
two
seasons
at
Inverleith before
joining Carlton in
1993. He won
SM’s
best
bat
award in 1992,
when
he
averaged 53.90.
Nazish
Hussain,
originally a RH player,
joined Carlton in 1999
from SMRH. In 64
first team matches he
took 60 wkts.

Text of this page
Rob Thornton
I came to Scotland in 1995 as overseas
amateur for Royal High FPs and, like
many, I caught the Edinburgh bug and
stayed on. Returning from Christmas in
Aus for the 1997 season I was told we
had merged with Stewart’s Melville,
‘…., oh and you’re captain.’ Like any
post merger arrangement there were a
few teething problems and I found it
quite daunting. However, we had a
very good mix of youth and experience
with players like Zahid Ali and Nazish
Hussain (who would both later play for
Carlton) Asim Butt, Alan Speirs, Ayaz
Gul, Brian Townsend and a great pro
Zahoor Elahi.
We had some great moments and
believe it or not, won the Masterton
final at Grange Loan in 1998 and made
it to the Scottish Cup Final.
I was very fortunate to open the
batting with test cricketer Zahoor, who
scored runs for fun, and he was front
and centre in my most memorable
game which happened to be at Grange
Rob Thornton arrived at Royal High
as
Overseas
Amateur
wicketkeeper/batsman in 1995. He
stayed for the following season and
continued with SMRH following the
merger. He was SMRH’s best bat in
1998, scoring 621 runs.
Rob remembers the merger and a
subsequent match with Carlton at
Grange Loan in 1997.
Loan against a Carlton team which
included Ced, Bryn, Jamie, a very
young
Fraggle
and
Craig
Bulloch.
Zahoor had just scored a double
century against Strathmore (extremely
rare in one day cricket in those days).
We batted first and after I had departed
(for 42 caught Watts bowled Spike
McLeod), Zahoor started to go through
the gears. It became very clear he was
playing a different game to the rest of
us, smashing it everywhere including a
couple of massive sixes over the score
box on the offside - which I have never
seen repeated at GL. Another double
century for Zahoor beckoned but he fell
for a mere 170.
As pointed out later by Carlton skipper
Spike, I probably should have declared
at some point but I was enjoying the
entertainment
and
in
the
second
innings after we had Ced out first ball
Carlton shut up shop to secure a losing
draw.
Ced was caught behind by me off Alan
Spiers’ first ball. What goes round
comes round. Approximately 16 years
later after successfully playing together
at Carlton for circa 15 years, I bowled
to Ced opening the batting for SMRH at
Inverleith. He was out for a duck
caught behind. (see match report on
the following page) Both times Ced
walked off muttering ‘how did I not hit
that (insert expletive) for six.’ Happy
days!
I had always enjoyed playing at Grange
Loan and was great mates with Jamie
so after a year off, I joined Carlton in
2000.
The rest is history. Rob made his
Carlton debut in June 2000 and
went on to make 108 first team
appearances. He was a highly
successful skipper of the 2nd XI in
2015 and 2016 and junior coach.
He and his family returned to
Australia at the end of 2016.

Text of this page
Carlton found themselves in the field
and got off to a great start as ex
Carlton player and prize wicket Cedric
was caught by a genuine Jaffa down the
leg side off Rob’s bowling. After this
genuine delivery came a genuine run
out thanks to the Aussie boy.
Omar was the surprise call up for this
game as statistics show he has been
short of wickets this season. Once again
he was satisfactory, picking up 2
wickets.
Frallardice
went
hoovering
about once more and picked up 3
wickets, all nicked off on the boundary.
Top effort from him.
At teas, I did not expect to put on my
pads let alone have a bat as the chase
was 121 to win.
We started off with Hamo and Kylo
batting - very test match as usual. After
the loss of the two Carlton were 33 for
2.
A Match to Remember?
SMRH v Carlton
20 July 2013
Inverlieth
SMRH 120ao; Carlton 121-9
Match Report by
Chayank Gosain (13-5-18-2)
Now what happened next I cannot
describe as we were soon 42 for 5 as
Preston, Stirlo and Drummo were out
cheaply thus leaving it to Fraggle and
JK to build a partnership. After some
crucial runs Fraggle dragged one onto
his stumps. Score now 88 for 6.
Still haven't got my pads on as I have
faith in JK and Rob ...
Score now 109 for 7 and Rob has also
played on.
Still have faith in Frallardice and JK to
get 12 runs ...
10 runs later I find myself going into
bat after Frallardice had missed a
straight one.
It’s 2 to win and I’m with boom boom
Omar. We clearly knew our options …
which was to wait for the bowler to
bowl a wide.
After
4
maidens
the
tension
was
building but we stuck to our plan and it
finally paid off. A great relief for the
team as we had just avoided a crisis for
the second time this season.
Special mention to Omar for managing
to stick in with me in that tense
situation after playing and missing at 5
in a row.
Players - a footnote
Fantasy Bob was a
stalwart
of
the
Royal High 2nd XI
from
1982
until
1994. FB never
played at Grange
Loan
in
those
years.
He
recommenced
his
not
so
glittering
career with Carlton
4th XI in 2008. He
has
made
133
appearances for
the 4th XI, the vast majority as skipper,
and has written the occasional match
report.

Text of this page
The history of Stewart’s Melville CC is
associated with several playing fields, a
number of which are now sadly lost to
cricket forever.
Stewart’s
Melville’s
present
ground
(above) at Inverleith was purchased in
1894
by
the
Governors
of
Daniel
Stewarts Hospital, from the Governors
of the Fettes Trust.
The eastern part of the ground - the
present rugby pitch and stand - had
been purchased in 1897 by the Scottish
Football Union (as the SRU was known
at the time), who thus became the first
of the home unions to own and run its
own
rugby
field.
The
first
rugby
international there was played in 1899
against Ireland and internationals were
played
until
January
1925
when
insufficient
space
to
accommodate
growing numbers of spectators caused
the SRU to move to Murrayfield.
The Inverleith ground was then sold to
the Merchant Company in 1926. In the
early 1900s the rugby ground was also
used for cricket. The groundsman at the
time was a very keen cricketer and Leith
Caledonian Cricket Club were granted
summer
lease
of
the
ground.
Caledonian went out of existence at the
time of the First World War.
The Inverleith artificial wicket, the first
in the area, and so familiar to Carlton’s
lower and junior sides, was installed in
1982, following the sale of Ferryfield,
see further below.
STEWART’S MELVILLE - THE GROUNDS - A SHORT HISTORY
Edinburgh
Institution
CC
played
originally at Warriston (where softball is
now more commonly played). From
1907 they played at Ferryfield, which
lay on the other side of Ferry Road from
Inverleith.
Ferryfield was sold for housing when
Stewart’s and Melville Colleges merged.
The last match at Ferryfield main
square was on 28 June 1981 against
Selkirk. The second square remained in
use until the end of the 1986 season,
usually mainly by the SM’s 2nd and
Sunday XIs. /cont’d over
Inverleith is
noted for its
balmy
summer
temperatures

Text of this page
Cont’d/
Royal High School FP originally played
at Holyrood (below) - roughly where
the Scottish Parliament now stands.
A pavilion was erected in 1868 to
replace
a
sentry
box
which
had
previously
served.
Large
crowds
regularly attended - newspaper reports
frequently
mention
thousands
in
attendance.
Two
games
were
accommodated at times although space
seems to have been limited. In 1877 it
is reported that in the match against
Carlton, A Buchanan, one of Royal
High’s leading batters, was ‘run out
because of another match taking place
on the same field.’
The Club continued to play at Holyrood
for 60 years, with the last match being
played
on
28
May
1921
against
Edinburgh Institution. The FP club
then purchased Jock’s Lodge (bottom
right) as a memorial to their fellows
who had fallen in WW1 and the first
match there, against Grange, took
place on 4 June 1921. A substantial
pavilion (below) was built in 1925.
The Royal High School relocated to
Barnton in 1970. Although the FP clubs
remained at Jock’s Lodge for a time, the
upkeep of the large ground was too
much without the link to the school and
the ground was sold in the late 1980s.
The
new
ground
at
East
Barnton
Avenue, adjacent to the school, was
completed for the 1990 season.
The memorial gates (above) which once
stood
at
Jock’s
Lodge
were
also
relocated. Barnton is now the home
ground of RH Corstorphine CC, which
has no relation with the former RHCC.
It was formed from the merger of
Corstorphine CC and the Royal High
Athletic Clubs in 2003. Corstorphine
previously played at Union Park in
Corstorphine. While rugby continues to
be played at Union Park, cricket no
longer is.

Text of this page
SUCCESS AT LORDS
Will Hardie reports
Rory McCann, Angus Beattie and I were
lucky enough to spend Sunday 31 July
playing at Lords for MCC Scotland. It was a
memorable
day,
with
MCC
Scotland
coming out victorious after defeating MCC
West Midlands in the semifinal and then
having a very comprehensive win over
London North in the final.
It was a very surreal feeling turning up at
Lords in the morning for a game of cricket!
We had a brief net on the nursery ground
before being treated like kings and served
lunch in the players’ dining room where
the England players usually dine.
After this it was game time. Thankfully
over the course of the day all the Carlton
representatives managed to contribute
with Beattie doing particularly well taking
five wickets across the 2 games. McCann
and I managed to hit a few bombs
between us into the Tavern Stand.
Upon completion of the game, it was a
swift turnaround into number 1s and time
for copious amounts of beer and canapes
starting in the Long Room at Lords and
then into the Big Smoke! All in all, what an
amazing experience to play at the Mecca
of cricket and even better to do it with
some fellow arrows.
Friday 2 September
Junior prize giving &
BBQ
Saturday 3 September
World Famous
Carlton Sixes -
teams compete for
the prestigious
Martin Flynn Trophy
Pizza Geeks in
attendance
throughout the day.
To be followed by
Senior Prizegiving
with street food
available.
END OF SEASON
EXCITEMENTS
Watch Pitchero
and WhatsApp
for more details

Text of this page
KWIK CRICKET FESTIVAL
We held our "annual" Kwik Cricket festival a
couple of Sundays ago, after the enforced 2
year break. It was as if nothing had
happened in two years: players and coaches
slotted
seamlessly
into
the
old
familiar
patterns; tea, coffee, juice and cakes poured
refreshingly from the clubhouse; the sun
shone; and the cricket shone even brighter.
We were joined by teams from Linlithgow,
MDAFS,
StewMel
and
Watsonians.
Impressively,
Linlithgow
had
so
many
enthusiastic cricketers that we formed a
combined Linlithgow/Carlton team in addition
to their own team. Carlton Juniors' appetite
for Kwik Cricket remains undimmed - 3
Carlton teams made up the ideal total of 8
teams. Grange Loan is a sight to behold on
Kwik Cricket Festival mornings: instead of the
normal 15 players and umpires dotted at
intervals around the ground, the outfield is a
riot of colour and activity: 64 players, 8
coaches and innumerable spectators jostle for
space; and the pitches are so close together
that balls frequently intrude into the wrong
game. But the players seem to love it, and
go home slightly wiser cricketers.
The cricket is played at an impeccably high
level of enthusiasm. At this level, results are
secondary to enjoyment (read: I'm having a
bit of trouble interpreting some of the
scoresheets), but I notice that all the Carlton
teams won one game, and most of them
sportingly allowed our visitors to win one too.
As a result of this remarkable hospitality,
everyone went home happy.
Many thanks to all the parents who gave up
their Sunday mornings to coach a team or to
feed the visitors.
JUNIOR SIXES
Sunday 31 July: 30 players, 9 noble volunteer
parents and a handful of spectators resist the
lure of the ODI going on across town, and
convene at Grange Loan for the Second
Annual Carlton CC Junior 6s.
Teams comprise (roughly) a player from each
Junior hardball squad, expertly led by the
older players. The day starts quietly, players
sizing up their team-mates: younger players
wondering what they have got themselves
into; older players eyeing the enormous gaps
in the field. Gradually, realisation dawns:
everyone is in this game, all the time.
Younger players grow suddenly taller, older
players relax as they realise that everyone is a
Carton cricketer.
After just two years, a pattern is emerging:
teams all win at least one game, and Red wins
overall - congratulations to Robbie, Harrison,
Magnus, Noah, Oscar & Sacha. But wait:
Green beat Red, Yellow beat Green, Orange
beat Yellow and Blue beat Orange ... they are
all winners!
Bowling is hard with only 4 outfielders.
Nonetheless, Hector managed a maiden,
Sacha went one better with a wicket maiden,
and Aaradhy trumped them both with a
remarkable triple-wicket maiden.
Batting looks easier, although high scores are
hard to come by as batters are limited to 9
balls. Aadi, Fergus F, and Robbie all managed
20s before being hauled off, but the batting
crown goes to Jake for doing it twice.
Fielding involves covering hundreds of yards,
and was of a high standard throughout. Three
catches stick in the mind: Noah and Hector
both ran a lo-o-ong way to take high catches.
But
the
most
incredible
catch
was
a
one-handed grab at slip by Harrison. To start
with, what on earth is a slip doing in a 6s
game?
Very well played to everyone, and a huge
thank you to Andrew, Doug, Euan, Graeme,
Johann, Jon, Keith & Malcolm for giving up a
whole Sunday to run the show.
Martin Firth celebrates
the post-COVID return
of Kwik Cricket and
Junior Sixes

Text of this page
PRIMARY COLOURS
Carlton’s Primary School team provides
additional hardball cricket opportunities to
state school cricketers. Over the years,
playing
most
of
Edinburgh’s
private
schools in a variety of formats, the
programme has helped produce multiple
1st
XI
cricketers
and
youth
internationalists and maintained a steady
supply of committed Carlton stalwarts.
Graduate of the Primary Team, 1st XI
skipper Tom Simpson has returned to
his roots by helping out this season.
He reports on the action in May and
June before the schools broke up.
This year saw the arrival of many new
faces to the Primary squad, lots playing
hardball cricket for the very first time! The
8 aside pairs format made getting teams
together a little easier and the pain of
getting a first ball duck somewhat more
tolerable. It also helped to produce some
very memorable finishes to tight games. In
both fixtures vs Loretto the match came
down to the final ball, the first in large part
due to a tremendous final over from young
P5 Tom Sweet who was inches away from
a maiden hat-trick!
The enthusiasm of the squad was fantastic
throughout, and really showed in the
commitment demonstrated in the field.
Some fantastic catches were taken across
the season, and after some introduction to
the importance of backing up/ ‘action and
reaction’, the team looked more and more
organised each week.
What is particularly exciting about the
group is the youth of the side. With a high
number of P5s and P6s, there is a great
opportunity to maintain a similar team next
year and to build and keep developing
other new players coming through.
GOOD LUCK
to Annette Aitken-Drummond and her team
as they attempt to retain the Beyond
Boundaries T20 Cup at Falkland CC on Sunday
21 August.

Text of this page
Sandy Crerar undertook a wide range
of committee tasks including bar/house
convenor and Membership Secretary for
a time in the 1980-90's and helped out
around the ground. He lived in West
Grange Gardens just across the road
from Grange Loan where he was able
‘to keep an eye on things.’
Nan Barwick came to
Edinburgh in 1995 following
a career in special needs
education in Melbourne. In
a long and close association
with the club, she became a
much loved mother figure
to generations of players.
Overseas
amateurs
and
juniors
in
particular
benefitted
from
her
kindness, good humour and
understanding.
The
special
place
of
Margaret
Masterton in Carlton’s history has
previously been described in the
Newsletter. She was Honorary Life
President
between
1968-88.
A
number of benches she presented
over 50 years ago are a small but
fitting testimony to her enduring
support for the club. However her
contribution
was
recognised
well
beyond the boundaries of Grange
Loan, as the bench presented by
ESCA attests - a recognition not only
of her dedication of the Masterton
trophy
but
on
her
continuing
contribution to cricket in the East of
Scotland.
MORE GRANGE LOAN BENCHES
